I can’t think of any dish more appropriately labeled “comfort food” than Beef Pot Pie. Truly excellent pot pies are hard to come by but this method will deliver the most tender and deeply flavored beef pie recipe you’ve ever made. The filling is braised in the oven until the meat is melt-in-your-mouth tender, then topped with pie crust dough and returned to the oven. This finishes into one special dish that will have everyone saying “yu-um” with every bite.
The recipe here, adapted from Cook’s Country, takes a bit of time, but is easy and not entirely hands-on. It is, however, quicker than many other pot pie recipes I’ve tried, and the ingredients in this dish come together for a complex, satisfying flavor.
In a Dutch-oven, browning just half of the beef before stewing imparts the rich, deep flavor of searing without overcrowding the pan and having to do two batches. The juices from the browned portion of the roast will help flavor your vegetables in the initial saute’ and the remaining meat will release flavorful juices in the oven.
Ingredients needed to make Beef Pot Pie-
The following list is not the complete list for this recipe so for shopping, use the printable recipe to purchase all ingredients and quantities needed-
- Beef Chuck-eye Roast- You may substitute sirloin steak here if you like but the cost is a bit higher.
- Mushrooms, onions, garlic, carrots, frozen peas- these are the vegetables I use in the recipe but you can skip what you don’t like or substitute. For instance, I love to use frozen pearl onions for the chopped onion now and then.
- Beef broth, soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, bay leaf, fresh thyme, all-purpose flour- these are the main ingredients, as well as the juices from the beef, that will create the delicious base for the beef and vegetables in the beef pot pie.
- Pie crust- You may make your own pie crust or buy pre-made pie crust. The recipe only calls for crust on the top, but you can make a double crust for this beef pot pie, but I recommend blind baking or par-baking the bottom crust before filling.
- Egg for an egg wash to provide a nice sheen to your pie crust- this is optional but nice looking.
Can Beef Pot Pie be made ahead of serving?
Absolutely. especially if you want to make the filling ahead of time and then assemble to bake with the pie crust the day of serving. The filling can be completed and then refrigerated up to two days, or sealed in an air-tight container and frozen for up to three months. The day of assembly, if your filling is refrigerated, no extra time is necessary for baking the pie. If you freeze the filling, I would defrost the filling in the refrigerator overnight before assembling the pie.
How to make homemade beef pot pie?
In a Dutch-oven, browning just half of the beef before stewing imparts the rich, deep flavor of searing without overcrowding the pan and having to do two batches. The juices from the browned portion of the roast will help flavor your vegetables in the initial sauté and the remaining meat will release flavorful juices in the oven.
Browning the vegetables makes a nice caramelization for added flavor, cooking until soft. Key ingredients are then added for the most flavorful pot pie in case I’ve failed to mention that this recipe is “flavorful” – tomato paste, garlic and red wine (the wine can be substituted for water, if need be). Then add good-quality beef broth, soy sauce, Worcestershire and bay leaf.
Finally, add all the beef into the mix and bake this filling in the oven for about an hour and a half or until the meat is tender.
After oven-braising the filling, remove to bowl. Then add a bit of water to your Dutch-oven and scrape off some of the fond that accumulated on the side of the pan. Add this complex, flavorful juice to your meat filling for optimal flavor and extra moisture.
Now we’re ready to put everything together for this “bring on the cold weather” juicy pot pie. But first let me talk to you about your pie crust. I am a true make-it-all-from-scratch kind of cook. But from time to time, I’ve used store-bough pie crusts and have had excellent results with them. Just do what’s easy for you. But if you’re looking for an easy homemade recipe, the crust for my Foolproof Berry Galette is so easy, delicious, and is completely and easily made in a food processor.
Here it is fresh out of the oven, you just know it’s going to be good. Really good! This Beef Pot Pie is going to be served around here quite often and I hope you’ll also give it a try. You won’t be disappointed. The recipe yields 6 servings, but everyone will want seconds so be prepared. Seldom will you have leftovers, but if you do, this recipe is delightful the next day and even more so the day after that.
Filling options for homemade Beef Pot Pie-
As I mention in the ingredient list above, you can use beef chuck roast or sirloin steak for the beef pot pie. I would not change out the ingredients that create the beefy-delicious broth for this recipe, it’s already so good. But we all have our preferences for the vegetables that go into our pot pie- Some other ingredients that are also delicious are- diced potato or parsnip, chopped celery, pearl onions, green beans. Use what you like but try to keep the quantity of vegetables about the same as the original recipe so your meat to veggie ratio is good, and you also have plenty of thick broth to encase the filling.
Recipe tested, slightly changed and adapted from Cook’s Country.
Through this article, we hope to help you understand Beef pot pie leftover roast