The Perfect Butter Pecan Ice Cream


Pecan season is here, and what could be more delightful than indulging in the warm weather with a scoop of creamy and nutty butter pecan ice cream? Although typically associated with fall, this delectable treat is perfect for the spring and summer months. Luckily, there are numerous store-bought options available to satisfy your cravings. Let’s dive into the world of butter pecan ice cream and discover the best options out there.

All About Butter Pecan Ice Cream

Every butter pecan ice cream starts with a luscious custard or ice cream base. Brown sugar, toasted pecans, and butter are added to create a delightful blend that tantalizes your taste buds with its sweet and buttery flavor. While store-bought variations may differ slightly in taste and texture, they all maintain the essence of this beloved flavor.

Nutritional Information

It’s no secret that ice cream is not a diet food, and butter pecan ice cream is no exception. A single serving typically contains 10% of your daily value of carbohydrates. On the bright side, it also offers a substantial amount of vitamin A, calcium, and potassium. Although there is minimal vitamin C and dietary fiber, it’s better than none at all.

Ranking the Best Butter Pecan Ice Creams

To make your freezer stash selection easier, we have compiled a list of the finest butter pecan ice creams available. Additionally, if you’re feeling adventurous and want to create your own homemade version, we’ve got a delightful recipe just for you.

See also  Planet Oat Ice Cream: A Delicious Dairy-Free Treat

4. Turkey Hill Butter Pecan

Made with salted pecan pralines, this ice cream boasts hints of butterscotch and vanilla. However, it ranks last due to slightly bitter pecans and a texture that tends to be icier, even after thawing.

3. Blue Bunny Butter Pecan

Blue Bunny is renowned for its vast selection of ice creams, including regular butter pecan and caramel butter pecan praline. While both options feature a rich vanilla ice cream base, they lack the desired amount of pecans.

2. Great Value Butter Pecan

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly treat, Walmart’s Great Value brand offers a rich and creamy option. With less fat than our top pick, it provides a satisfying flavor without breaking the bank.

1. Haagen-Dazs Butter Pecan

Topping our list as the winner, Haagen-Dazs offers a creamy, rich, and pecan-packed experience. It’s no surprise that this indulgent delight contains higher sugar and fat content. With over 300 calories in only 2/3 cup, it’s a treat to savor and enjoy in moderation. Thankfully, it contains only 0.5 g of trans fat.

DIY Butter Pecan Ice Cream Recipe

For those who love a culinary adventure, try making your own butter pecan ice cream. This homemade version is not only delicious but also surprisingly simple to create. To achieve a silky, creamy texture, you’ll need an ice cream maker. What sets this recipe apart is the inclusion of browned butter and toasted nuts. The brown butter adds a rich and nutty flavor, while toasting the pecans enhances their natural sweetness. The total time required is over 24 hours, with a preparation time of approximately 4 hours. We recommend making this recipe a few days in advance of when you plan to indulge. For an extra touch of decadence, you can even add chocolate chips. This butter pecan ice cream pairs beautifully with a warm brownie and a dollop of fresh whipped cream.

See also  Make Your Own Ice Cream Sandwiches at Home!

To access the full recipe, click here.


Butter pecan ice cream is a beloved treat that combines the richness of butter, the sweetness of pecans, and the creaminess of ice cream. Whether you opt for a store-bought option or decide to embark on a homemade adventure, indulging in this flavorful delight is always a great choice. Treat yourself to the finest butter pecan ice cream available and savor every spoonful of this seasonal sensation.

Image source: Family Cuisine

Related Posts

Mason Jar Ice Cream - A Delicious Summer Recipe

Mason Jar Ice Cream – A Delicious Summer Recipe

Ice cream is a universally loved dessert that satisfies everyone’s sweet tooth. There’s something about that creamy texture and delightful taste that just hits the spot. And…

Dairy-Free Ice Cream Bars: A Delicious Frozen Dessert for Everyone!

Dairy-Free Ice Cream Bars: A Delicious Frozen Dessert for Everyone!

Who doesn’t love a creamy and indulgent ice cream bar? In my previous article, I shared the top 15 dairy-free ice cream pints. But today, I want…

Making Homemade Ice Cream with Kitchenaid

Making Homemade Ice Cream with Kitchenaid

Video kitchenaid ice cream recipes Have you ever craved a scoop of delicious, creamy ice cream but didn’t want to leave the house? Well, thanks to KitchenAid,…

Indulge in the Hottest Lactose-Free Ice Cream This Summer

Indulge in the Hottest Lactose-Free Ice Cream This Summer

It seems like every day there’s a new kind of ice cream hitting the market. From dairy-free to animal-free, from fat-free to sugar-free, the options are endless….

Say Goodbye to Hard Ice Cream with the Midnight Scoop

Video heated ice cream scoop Are you tired of struggling with hard ice cream? We know the feeling! There’s nothing quite like the joy of indulging in…

Protein Shake Ice Cream: A Delicious and Protein-Packed Treat

Protein Shake Ice Cream: A Delicious and Protein-Packed Treat

If you’re looking for a guilt-free way to satisfy your sweet tooth while getting a protein boost, look no further than this Ninja Creami protein ice cream…