- We tasted vanilla milkshakes from 5 quick meals chains to see which one is greatest.
- We tried shakes from McDonald’s, Chick-fil-A, Burger King, Dairy Queen, and Wendy’s.
- Chick-fil-A got here in first place and Burger King got here in second; each of their shakes tasted do-it-yourself and had probably the most genuine vanilla taste.
- McDonald’s got here in final due to its overwhelmingly synthetic style.
- Go to INSIDER’s house web page for extra tales.
A vanilla milkshake might appear to be a slightly mundane dessert choice, however discover one with a creamy, genuine vanilla taste and it will fulfill even the sweetest of candy tooths.
We examined the deal with at 5 completely different quick meals chains to see which one is greatest. The variations we sampled have been from:
Reading: Best fast food vanilla milkshake
- Burger King
- Dairy Queen
Hold scrolling to learn our ideas and to see the ultimate rating.
McDonald’s McCafé Vanilla Shake
Our first cease was a McCafé, McDonald’s espresso store that is largely identified for its espresso, pastries, and candy drinks. We ordered the vanilla shake, which, at simply $2 for a small, is an especially reasonably priced technique to deal with your self. The drink is made with McDonald’s vanilla gentle serve and comes topped with a wholesome dollop of whipped cream.
At first sip, we have been struck by the overwhelming sweetness of the shake. It was loaded with vanilla taste, however the form of synthetic vanilla taste that serves as a tell-tale signal you are consuming one thing from a fast-food chain versus one thing do-it-yourself. Whereas McDonald’s obtained the creaminess and the feel of the milkshake proper, the flavour left one thing to be desired.
Learn extra: I attempted to order 9 issues from McDonald’s ‘secret menu’ — but it surely was a a lot larger problem than I anticipated
Chick-fil-A’s Vanilla Milkshake
We had excessive expectations for Chick-fil-A, largely as a result of the chain refers to their vanilla shake as being hand spun, a time period which means the milkshake is hand combined by a human slightly than a machine. Plus, it is made with “Icedream,” which the chain describes as “a delicious, dairy treat with an old-fashioned vanilla taste.”
The deal with exceeded expectations. Apparently, handspinning makes a distinction, as a result of Chick-fil-A achieved the do-it-yourself style that McDonald’s so clearly lacked. The vanilla taste was each scrumptious and genuine, and though the shake was a little bit over $4, it was a heaping portion that spilled over the perimeters of the cup. A vibrant purple Maraschino cherry added a pleasant — if largely aesthetic — contact.
Burger King’s Vanilla Hand Spun Shake
Our subsequent cease was Burger King, whose vanilla shake can also be hand spun. And that wasn’t its solely similarity to Chick-fil-A’s milkshake. Burger King’s model was about the identical measurement and price just about the identical. The style was comparable too — creamy, genuine, not too candy.
We have been pleasantly stunned by the shake. Prior to now, we have discovered that BK’s savory choices do not normally dwell as much as different chains’ like McDonald’s or Wendy’s. However we actually loved this deal with, which served as additional proof that milkshakes combined by people are higher than milkshakes combined by machines.
Learn extra: We tried the three least expensive meals at Burger King, McDonald’s, and Wendy’s. Here is which meal left us fullest.
Dairy Queen’s Vanilla Shake
Since Dairy Queen is a sequence that is identified for its ice cream — specifically its blizzards — we have been excited to attempt their vanilla shake. Like at Chick-fil-A and Burger King, the milkshake was hand spun and a measurement small value simply over $4. Nevertheless, it was noticeably smaller.
Our first style was certainly one of blandness and disappointment. The shake did not have a lot vanilla taste; it tasted extra like milk than the rest. The chain’s web site describes the drink as “vanilla soft serve blended with vanilla syrup and milk…” Possibly the one who combined our shake did not get the vanilla to exploit ratio proper, or perhaps that is simply how DQ shakes are. Both means, we weren’t all that impressed.
Wendy’s Vanilla Frosty
Wendy’s was our final cease. The chain does not provide a vanilla milkshake, however they do provide a vanilla Frosty, which they confer with as “a cool, creamy, real-milk dairy dessert.” For many who are unfamiliar with a Frosty, it is principally a barely extra frozen and fewer liquid model of a shake.
The deal with was by far the most cost effective of the 5 we tried ($1.08). That stated, it is undoubtedly not hand spun, contemplating we have been handed one straight from a freezer upon ordering. The Frosty was good, but it surely actually did not blow us away. It tasted quite a bit like your common vanilla gentle serve, however in a beverage cup as a substitute of a cone. When you let it sit and soften for a bit, you may finally drink the Frosty like a daily milkshake, which is what we did.
After ending our style check, we determined that Chick-fil-A and Burger King have been the highest two contenders. These shakes tasted probably the most do-it-yourself, and had probably the most genuine vanilla taste out of all 5 of the drinks. If we had tried the 2 of them blindfolded, we would not have guessed they have been the product of quick meals chains. Ultimately, we merely appreciated the style of Chick-fil-A’s higher — however solely by a little bit bit. That may very well be as a result of BK provides “vanilla sauce” to their shakes, which sounds synthetic. Chick-fil-A does not add sauce.
We weren’t loopy about Wendy’s Frosty, however there wasn’t something that was essentially dangerous about it, which is why the deal with earned third place. DQ beat out McDonald’s as a result of, though it lacked taste, we would slightly have some blandness than a complete lot of synthetic taste, which is what we skilled with the McCafé shake.
For a really satisfying vanilla milkshake, your greatest guess is Chick-fil-A or Burger King. When you’re keen to sacrifice style for worth, then go together with a Wendy’s Frosty. If you end up at a Dairy Queen or McDonald’s, bask in one of many many different treats the chains provide; you may depart a happier buyer.
Read more: Best ice cube tray for baby food
- Learn extra:
- I attempted 10 quick meals chocolate milkshakes — and there is one I might choose each time
- We examined the recipes from Nestle, Hershey’s, and Ghirardelli chocolate chip packages, and the winner was clear
- We tried chocolate glazed donuts from 4 bakery chains and the winner additionally had probably the most glaze
- We tried smoothies from 5 completely different chains and the winner tasted creamy and recent