Soft and Delicious Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich Cookies

This article may contain affiliate links. Read the full disclosure here.

Who doesn’t love sinking their teeth into a delectable ice cream sandwich? The combination of tender vanilla cookies embracing creamy ice cream creates a delightful treat that is perfect for indulging in during the warm summer months. Join me as we explore how to make these homemade ice cream sandwich cookies that are sure to become a favorite at your next barbecue gathering.

A Summer Dessert Must-Have

As we eagerly await the arrival of summer, we yearn for longer days, balmy evenings, and mouthwatering BBQ dinners paired with refreshing desserts. Among the array of summer treats, ice cream sandwiches hold a special place in my heart. These homemade ice cream sandwich cookies resemble classic shortbread, boasting rich vanilla flavor. However, I have meticulously adjusted the butter, flour, and sugar ratios to ensure they turn out irresistibly soft.

The Secret to Soft Cookies

When it comes to ice cream sandwiches, soft cookies are paramount. Nobody wants to bite into a rock-hard frozen treat. Rest assured, these ice cream sandwich cookies maintain their incredible softness and slight chewiness even after freezing. The key is to slightly underbake the cookies, resulting in a cookie that perfectly melds with the ice cream.

Unleash Your Creativity

While I kept the cookies simple with just a touch of vanilla extract for flavoring, feel free to get fancy and customize your cookies to suit your taste buds. Experiment with different extracts such as almond or mint, or add mini chocolate chips, toffee bits, or sprinkles for an extra burst of excitement.

See also  Family Cuisine Presents: The Delight of Signature Select Ice Cream

Step-by-Step Guide

Let’s dive into the process of crafting these delectable ice cream sandwich cookies. Don’t worry; it’s easier than you might think!

What You’ll Need

To get started, gather the following ingredients:

  • Butter (unsalted and softened to room temperature)
  • Confectioners’ sugar (powdered sugar, sifted)
  • Vanilla extract (homemade or high-quality natural extract)
  • Salt (just a pinch for balancing flavors)
  • All-purpose flour (properly measured and sifted for a light and airy consistency)
  • Optional mix-ins (chocolate chips, sprinkles, butterscotch chips, coconut flakes, or toffee chips)
  • Single-serving ice cream cups (4 ounces each) in your favorite flavor

Recommended Tools

Make sure you have these handy tools before you begin:

  • Rolling pin
  • Baking sheets
  • Parchment paper
  • Electric mixer


  1. Cream the butter and sugar: In a large bowl, use a hand mixer or stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment to beat the butter and sugar until creamy and well combined.
  2. Add in the vanilla and dry ingredients: Beat in the vanilla and salt, then gradually add the sifted flour. Mix on low speed until thoroughly combined. If desired, incorporate your chosen mix-ins.
  3. Chill the dough: Divide the dough in half and shape each half into a disk. Wrap tightly in plastic wrap and refrigerate for 30 minutes.
  4. Roll the dough: Roll each dough disk to a thickness of approximately ¼ inch. Use a 2 and ½ inch round cookie cutter to cut out cookies, placing them about 1 inch apart on the prepared baking sheets.
  5. Bake: Preheat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Bake the cookies for 9-10 minutes, ensuring they appear slightly under-baked and soft. Leave the cookies on the baking sheet to cool completely.
  6. Assemble the ice cream sandwiches: Remove the lids and inner seals from the ice cream cups. Carefully cut away the packaging from the ice cream, and slice it horizontally into two equal discs. Sandwich each disc of ice cream between two cookie slices, and savor the deliciousness!
See also  When Can Babies Enjoy Delicious Ice Cream?

Soft ice cream sandwich cookie dough in a glass mixing bowl with a pink spatula.

Soft ice cream sandwich cookie dough shaped into two discs.

Unbaked soft ice cream sandwich cookies on a baking sheet lined with white parchment paper.

Pro Tips for Success

For the ultimate ice cream sandwich experience, follow these helpful tips:

  • Be mindful not to let the ice cream become too soft before slicing, as it may result in a messy affair.
  • Ensure the cookies have completely cooled before assembling the sandwich, providing the perfect texture contrast.
  • If you’re feeling adventurous, try making these ice cream sandwiches with some of my other favorite cookies, such as s’mores cookies, oatmeal butterscotch cookies, or chocolate peanut butter cookies.

Storage and Freezing

While these ice cream sandwich cookies are best enjoyed immediately, you can also store them for up to a month for future cravings. Individually wrap them in plastic wrap and place them in a freezer bag. When you’re ready to indulge, let them thaw slightly but not too much, striking the perfect balance between solidity and creaminess.

For more delectable recipes inspired by the love of family cuisine, visit Family Cuisine.

Recipe Snapshot

  • TASTE: Vanilla shortbread cookies enveloping your favorite ice cream flavors
  • TEXTURE: Crunchy cookies paired with smooth and cool ice cream
  • EASE: Easy!
  • TIME: Just under an hour, including chilling time

Related Posts

The Healthiest Ice Cream Brands

Ice cream is undeniably delicious, but can it be healthy too? With so many options on the market, it can be challenging to find the healthiest choice….

Where to Find the Best Superman Ice Cream in Michigan

By: Sherry Trautman | | Updated: July 10, 2023 As the summer heat intensifies in Michigan, people across the state are flocking to ice cream parlors,…

Schweddy Balls Ice Cream – A Cheeky Delight from Ben & Jerry’s

Video schweddy balls ice cream Ben & Jerry’s has once again pushed the boundaries of ice cream flavors with their latest creation: Schweddy Balls. This unique flavor…

Soft Serve Ice Cream Machine For Home

Going through our list of the best soft-serve ice cream makers in 2023 may have made you a little less indecisive than you were when your search…

Coolhaus: New Flavors and a Snazzy New Look for Dairy-Free Ice Cream Sandwiches

Coolhaus: New Flavors and a Snazzy New Look for Dairy-Free Ice Cream Sandwiches

Updated in 2021! Are you craving a cool and creamy treat without any animal products? Look no further than Coolhaus Dairy-Free Ice Cream Sandwiches. This iconic brand,…

Gingerbread Ice Cream Sandwiches

Yes, you read that title right. Gingerbread Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches!! Let me tell you, this idea is a game-changer. I wanted to create something with gingerbread,…