how to make a mai tai with pineapple juice

Making a Mai Tai is not as hard as it might seem. The key to making a good one is in the ingredients and the proportions. There are many recipes out there, but this one has been tested and proven to be delicious!

A Classic Mai Tai combines light and dark rums with orange liqueur and a splash of pineapple juice, the result is a citrusy, bright and smooth cocktail. Sipping this cocktail makes me feel like I’m lounging on a beach, listening to the sound of lapping waves.

If you’ve tried a Mai Tai in the past and been unimpressed with the sugary or overly fruity flavor, this classic version of the Mai Tai might change your mind.

Classic Mai Tai recipe by Barefeet In The Kitchen

Mai Tai Cocktail

My brother-in-law is known to make one heck of an incredible Mai Tai cocktail. His version made me realize that a Classic Mai Tai isn’t meant to be too heavy on the pineapple and orange flavors. I look forward to enjoying one of these whenever we visit.

The last time I visited my sister, I twisted my brother in law’s arm to show me how to make his classic version. This Mai Tai drink is very smooth and flavorful without being overly sweet.

The key difference in this Mai Tai recipe compared to others I’ve tried is waiting to add the pineapple juice at the very end. I shake the other ingredients in a cocktail shaker but leave the pineapple juice to add to the glass right at the end. This allows you to add as much or as little pineapple juice as you like in order to sweeten the drink.

I’d start with 2 oz. of pineapple juice then taste to see if you want a little more. If you enjoy the flavor of rum, you might even want to start with just a single shot (1.5 oz.) of pineapple juice before adding more to taste.

The only place I’ve found that makes a Mai Tai close to this version is PF Chang’s. As proven with the fabulous Coconut Lemon Sour, their bartenders definitely know how to mix a drink.

Mai Tai Ingredients

Using good quality ingredients is important with any cocktail and Mai Tai Cocktails are no different.

This a rum based cocktail that uses both light and dark varieties of rum. I’ve found the quality of the light rum doesn’t matter too much but you don’t want to use bottom of the barrel liquor. Bacardi or a similar standard shelf variety will work just fine.

When it comes to the dark rum, don’t skimp. Cheap dark rums just don’t have the same smoothness as the better stuff and smooth is one of the primary characteristics of a delicious well-made Mai Tai.

I use Mount Gay Rum most often when I make this drink but your favorite middle quality or top shelf dark rum will do. Don’t substitute spiced rums. They’ll disrupt the flavor balance in this cocktail.

Orgeat syrup is the secret ingredient that gives Mai Tais their distinct flavor. Made from blanched almonds and orange-flower water, Orgeat syrup has a sweet and nutty almond flavor that’s amazing paired with pineapple juice. There are several good brands of Orgeat syrup available or, if you’re feeling ambitious, you could even make your own.

This Classic Mai Tai gets its tropical citrus flavor from a dash of orange liqueur. Gran Gala is my preferred brand but feel free to substitute with whatever orange liqueur you have available.

Finally, the pineapple juice. Ideally, use 100% Pineapple Juice in this recipe rather than one that’s mainly added sugar. That fresh tropical pineapple flavor brings the flavors of citrus, almonds, and rum together for a cocktail that tastes like summer at the beach.

Cocktail Recipes

Looking for more delicious and easy cocktail recipes? I’ve got you covered. Like a Mai Tai, Pineapple Mojitos conjure images of lazy summer days by the ocean or pool, soaking up the sun. They’re one of the drinks I make most often and popular with everyone who tries one.

The Moscow Mule has fast become one of my favorite cocktails. Refreshing and citrusy with lime, vodka and ginger beer, it’s an easy go to for parties any time of the year.

My husband’s favorite drink is The Old-Fashioned. Not for the weak, an Old-Fashioned brings together Bourbon whiskey, bitters and soda water and is typically garnished with a maraschino cherry and an orange slice.

For something a little more unusual, check out this Brazilian Caipirinha Cocktail. The primary ingredient is Ypioca Cachaca, the most popular distilled liquor in Brazil. It’s a basic combination of the cane sugar based liquor served over ice with a twist of fresh lime juice.

Mai Tai Recipe

1. Combine 1 ounce of light rum, 1 ounce of dark rum, half an ounce of Orgeat syrup and 1/2 ounce of orange liqueur in a cocktail shaker with plenty of ice.

2. Shake well until the drink is chilled, then strain over crushed ice.

3. Add 2 – 3 ounces of pineapple juice and adjust the amount of juice to taste.

Traditionally, Mai Tais are served in an Old Fashioned glass. It makes for a beautiful, classic presentation. You can also serve this Mai Tai in a highball glass.

{originally published 10/23/12 – recipe notes updated 1/31/19}

0 ( 0 votes )

Family Cuisine

Family Cuisine - Instructions, how to, recipes for delicious dishes every day for your loved ones in your family

Readers' opinions (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts


desserts to make with dessert shells

07/10/2021 23:33 2036

Desserts to make with dessert shells can range in complexity, but they are all delicious and fun to make. Whether you want a quick snack or an elaborate dinner party dessert, these desserts have something for everyone!

Home Canned Marinara Sauce | Family Cuisine

11/08/2021 22:13 1908

Marinara sauce is a staple in many Italian households and it's easy to make. This recipe for home canned marinara sauce is simple and delicious.

How to make orange chicken sauce from panda express

22/08/2021 06:07 1638

The Panda Express Orange Chicken Sauce is a must-try dish. The orange sauce is made from sweet and sour chicken, soy sauce, garlic, ginger, orange juice and corn starch.

How to make homemade marinara sauce using fresh tomatoes

20/08/2021 11:49 1588

This is a quick and easy recipe for homemade marinara sauce. It's made with fresh tomatoes, garlic, onion, basil leaves, oregano, salt and pepper.

How to make spaghetti sauce from fresh tomatoes for canning

20/08/2021 17:51 1549

Making your own spaghetti sauce from fresh tomatoes is easy and delicious. This recipe is a great way to use up those tomatoes that are too ripe for eating, but not quite ready to be canned. In the process of making this sauce, you

Best Damn Air Fryer Pork Tenderloin

12/08/2021 00:27 1159

A review of the best air fryer pork tenderloin you can find.

How to build a santa maria grill

16/08/2021 22:01 999

Santa Maria Grill is a restaurant in the heart of downtown. We serve up delicious, healthy food in a comfortable setting.

Best Ever Enchilada Sauce Recipe (Tex Mex Chili Gravy) | Family Cuisine

12/08/2021 06:37 873

If you love Tex Mex and Mexican food, then this is the recipe for you. This best ever enchilada sauce recipe has just the right amount of spice with a hint of sweetness to make it perfect for any meal. It's

Load more