how to make delicious pizza sauce | Family Cuisine

If you are looking for a quick, easy sauce to make for your next pizza night, try this recipe. It is simple and delicious!

The BEST Homemade Pizza Sauce recipe is easy to make, luxuriously thick, and loaded with flavor. It will take your favorite pizza to the next level, and it also makes an amazing dipping sauce! via @fivehearthome

The BEST Pizza Sauce is easy to make, luxuriously thick, and loaded with flavor. This homemade pizza sauce recipe will take your favorite pie to the next it also makes an amazing dipping sauce!

The BEST Pizza Sauce with text overlay.

If you enjoy different types of pizza, you’ll love Caprese French Bread Pizza, Pineapple Pulled Pork Pizza with Bacon, Jalepeños, + Cilantro, or French Bread Taco Pizza!

My family likes pizza – a lot – so “Pizza Night” is a regular thing around these parts. Sometimes we order delivery, but more often than not, the kids help me whip up a few homemade pies. And regardless of the rotation of our favorite toppings, those pizzas always include this amazing, homemade, BEST Pizza Sauce!

I actually first shared this pizza sauce recipe six years ago as a dipping sauce for my kids’ beloved Pizza Quesadillas. And while those quesadillas are certainly tasty, it’s the sauce that always gets the rave reviews from recipe commenters. And I have to’s so tasty that once you try it, you won’t go back to whatever you used before!

Aerial view of labeled ingredients.


This recipe is very much a case of simple ingredients combining for amazing flavor.

  • Tomato puree OR tomato sauce. Tomato puree is thicker than tomato sauce, and it’s typically what I use when making Pizza Sauce. That being said, this recipe does thicken as it cooks, so tomato sauce will work as well. You could also use crushed tomatoes if you prefer.
  • Tomato paste. An essential addition thanks to its highly concentrated tomato flavor!
  • Sugar. My family enjoys a slightly sweet undertone in our Pizza Sauce, but a bit of sugar is also important for curbing the acidity of the tomatoes. However, you may certainly tweak the amount of sugar to your liking. You could also substitute honey.
  • Dried herbs. Namely, basil, oregano, parsley, and thyme. Keep in mind that this is an herby, flavor-packed bland sauce here!
  • Fennel seeds. SECRET INGREDIENT ALERT!!! I’ll be the first to admit that I hate licorice and I strongly dislike fennel. However, crushed fennel seeds are what set this Pizza Sauce apart from others! It’s the ingredient that will cause your house to smell like a pizzeria while making this recipe. And I promise that you will enjoy the flavor even if you happen to be a fellow licorice-hater. 😉 (See the next section for how to crush your fennel seeds.)
  • Garlic powder + onion powder.
  • Salt. I use fine sea familycuisine.netSalt is my favorite brand.
  • Crushed red pepper flakes. I usually add just a pinch, but feel free to stir in more for extra kick.

Jar of homemade Best Pizza Sauce with spoon.

How to Crush Fennel Seeds

Crushing the fennel seeds has two purposes. ONE, it releases their hence, their flavor. And TWO, who wants to bite into a whole fennel seed? The crushed bits blend much more smoothly into a sauce.

As far as how to crush your fennel seeds, there are various options.

  • You could of course whiz them up in a spice grinder, should you be lucky enough to own one of those. A clean coffee grinder would also work.
  • Using a mortar and pestle is typically my preferred method. Alas, when I unpacked my kitchen boxes after our last move, I located my the matching pestle was nowhere to be found. *adds to Amazon list*
  • So instead, I’ve been resorting to a good ol’ fashioned method knows as bashing the seeds instead.

Fennel seeds in a bag.

Simply put your fennel seeds into a small zip-top baggie and then gently pound and mash them with the flat side of a meat a rolling just about any other solid, heavy kitchen accoutrement you can find.

How to crush fennel seeds with a mallet.

Ta-daaaaa! Crushed fennel seeds.

Ingredients in pot to make Best Pizza Sauce recipe.

How to Make Pizza Sauce

Now it’s time to make the BEST Pizza Sauce! Ready for the oh-so-complicated steps?

  1. Combine all of the ingredients in a small saucepan.
  2. Bring to a simmer, reduce heat to a low simmer (AKA, occasional bubbles), and stir every 5 minutes or so.
  3. Cook until your sauce is thick, luxurious, and deeply flavored, which typically takes around 25 to 30 minutes. But if you’re in a hurry, you may certainly remove it from the heat after just 15 minutes or so.

And that’s it! Allow to cool a bit before spreading on your pizza.

Pizza Sauce Recipe being spread on a pizza.

Dipping Sauce Option

And don’t forget that this makes a fabulous dipping sauce as well! Serve warm for dunking meatballs, breadsticks, quesadillas, and so much more.


This pizza sauce recipe yields about 1 heaping cup. I find this to be the perfect amount for two 12- or 13-inch pizzas, though you may prefer more (or less?) sauce on a pizza. In that case, the recipe can easily be doubled or tripled.

Best Pizza Sauce being stirred together in pot.

Freezing It

This sauce will keep in the refrigerator for about a week.

Should you choose to make extra sauce, however, it freezes beautifully for up to 3 months. Simply thaw in the fridge overnight before you wish to use it.

Close-up of Best Pizza Sauce spread on pizza crust.

So who’s ready to make the tastiest Pizza Sauce ev-ah?!

Pizza Night will never be the same again. 🙂

More Italian-Inspired Recipes

  • One-Pot Pizza Pasta
  • Chicken Parmesan Meatballs
  • One-Pot Spaghetti
  • 30-Minute Skillet Lasagna

0 ( 0 votes )

Family Cuisine
Family Cuisine - Instructions, how to, recipes for delicious dishes every day for your loved ones in your family

Readers' opinions (0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts


desserts to make with dessert shells

07/10/2021 23:33 2036

Desserts to make with dessert shells can range in complexity, but they are all delicious and fun to make. Whether you want a quick snack or an elaborate dinner party dessert, these desserts have something for everyone!

Home Canned Marinara Sauce | Family Cuisine

11/08/2021 22:13 1904

Marinara sauce is a staple in many Italian households and it's easy to make. This recipe for home canned marinara sauce is simple and delicious.

How to make orange chicken sauce from panda express

22/08/2021 06:07 1635

The Panda Express Orange Chicken Sauce is a must-try dish. The orange sauce is made from sweet and sour chicken, soy sauce, garlic, ginger, orange juice and corn starch.

How to make homemade marinara sauce using fresh tomatoes

20/08/2021 11:49 1588

This is a quick and easy recipe for homemade marinara sauce. It's made with fresh tomatoes, garlic, onion, basil leaves, oregano, salt and pepper.

How to make spaghetti sauce from fresh tomatoes for canning

20/08/2021 17:51 1549

Making your own spaghetti sauce from fresh tomatoes is easy and delicious. This recipe is a great way to use up those tomatoes that are too ripe for eating, but not quite ready to be canned. In the process of making this sauce, you

Best Damn Air Fryer Pork Tenderloin

12/08/2021 00:27 1157

A review of the best air fryer pork tenderloin you can find.

How to build a santa maria grill

16/08/2021 22:01 998

Santa Maria Grill is a restaurant in the heart of downtown. We serve up delicious, healthy food in a comfortable setting.

Best Ever Enchilada Sauce Recipe (Tex Mex Chili Gravy) | Family Cuisine

12/08/2021 06:37 872

If you love Tex Mex and Mexican food, then this is the recipe for you. This best ever enchilada sauce recipe has just the right amount of spice with a hint of sweetness to make it perfect for any meal. It's

Load more